German Psychologists Declare “MIND Drugs Don’t Work”
Experts question the “emperor’s new treatments for mental illnesses”
In The News September 23, 2016 http://www. madinamerica.com/2016/09/
Jürgen Margraf and Silvia Schneider, both well-known psychologists at the University of Bochum in Germany,
claim that psychotropic drugs are no solution to mental health issues in an editorial for the latest issue of
the journal EMBO Molecular Medicine. They argue that the effects of psychiatric drugs for depression, anxiety,
and ‘ADHD’ are short-lived and may have negative long-term consequences.
“There are now plenty of data and evidence that, in the long term, the drugs do not work,” the authors write in
their commentary, “From neuroleptics to neuroscience and from Pavlov to psychotherapy: more than just the
‘emperor’s new treatments’ for mental illnesses?”
Margraf and Schneider begin by pointing out that the number of people in the industrialized world who are
disabled because of mental health issues has been rapidly rising over the past fifty years. At the same time,
they note, the common perception is that new antidepressant and anti-anxiety drugs and other new treatments
have greatly improved mental health treatment.
If this “epidemic” of mental health issues causing disability is not due to an increase in overall incidence,
they ask, “how can this apparent contradiction be explained?”
“Could it be,” they continue, “that therapeutic progress is much less than we think or are being told? Could it
be that the course of depression, anxiety, schizophrenia, or ADHD has been altered for the worse? Could it be
that we cannot make therapeutic progress because the concept of mental illness and its treatment is deeply
flawed? There are strong reasons to assume that all three suspicions are in fact true.”
The researchers identify three conceptual mistakes that are preventing more successful treatments for mental
health issues from being developed.
The “ill-advised biological notion of mental illnesses” and the “myth of the chemical imbalance”
The “reification of diagnostic constructs (like using the word ‘depression’) --as distinct illness categories”
rather than as a dimension of NORMAL human behavior occurring on a spectrum.
Reification is a complex idea for when you treat something immaterial — like happiness, fear, or evil —
as a material thing. This can be a way of making something concrete and easier to understand, like how a wedding ring is the
reification of a couple's love.
The emphasis on “bottom-up” causal pathways, like genetics, rather than “top down” social and psychological
“After decades of proclaimed therapeutic breakthroughs and promises of imminent better treatments based on the
translation of basic science into clinical practice, neither neurobiology nor neuroscience has led to
measurably better long-term outcomes for any of the major mental disorders,” they write. “Although psychotropic
drugs are by far the most often used treatment modality in industrialized countries, there is no compelling
evidence for the long-term stability of their small to moderate short-term results.”
Margraf and Schneider suggest that psychologists work together to bring a renewed focus to all three levels of
analysis, biological, psychological, and sociological, while pushing back against the “marketing power of Big Pharma.”
“A realistic assessment of our current treatment options and the close cooperation of clinicians and
neuroscientists would help us to overcome the current stagnation and put us back on the track forward,” they
<=== BACK TO THE FRUGAL TIPS and CHEAPO LIFESTYLE WEBPAGE
Our POSTER is ANITA SANDS HERNANDEZ, Los Angeles Writer, mother of 4 and career Astrologer. Catch up with her websites TRUTHS GOV WILL HIDE & NEVER TELL YOU, also The FUTURE, WHAT'S COMIN' AT YA! FRUGAL LIFE STYLE TIPS, HOW TO SURVIVE the COMING GREAT DEPRESSION, and Secrets of Nature, HOLISTIC, AFFORDABLE HEALING. Also ARTISANRY FOR EXPORT, EARN EUROS..and GUERILLA CAPITALISM 101
Anita is found at astrology @ earthlink.net Get a 15$ natal horoscope "my money/future life" reading now + copy horoscope as a Gif file graphic! No smarter, more accurate career reading out there!
<=== BACK TO TRACKING THE ECONOMY, an INDEX PAGE
<===BACK TO MONEY SECRETS ONLY THE EXPERTS KNOW
<=== BACK TO SECRETS THE GOV DOES NOT WANT YOU TO KNOW
<===BACK TO THE SECRETS OF THE OLIGARCHS, THE EMPIRE INDEX PAGE
<=== SHOW ME THE FIX INDEX PAGE.
<== SHOW ME THE HAPPY R)EVOLUTION PAGE
<=== BACK TO "GUERILLA CAPITALISM" -- THE SOLUTION!
<==== BACK TO THE "VITAL SIGNS OF A DYING ECONOMY" the "FUTURE" WEBPAGE
<==== BACK TO THE WALL STREET MELTDOWN WEBSITE, with "WHAT TO DO TO SURVIVE" TIPS
<=== BACK TO ENRON PLANET, the DOOMSDAY SCENARIO!
<====BACK TO THE HOLISTIC GOURMET, BON MARCHE
<=== BACK TO THE GLEENERS PAGE
<=== HOW EVEN A POOR PERSON CAN BUY REAL ESTATE
<== BACK TO THE FUTURE INDEX PAGE
<=== BACK TO THE GENTLEMAN FARMER'S GARDEN INDEX
<=== INVESTIGATE DOING DRIP IRRIGATE- LINES in DROUGHT TORN AREAS, LEARN IN A DAY, VERY LUCRATIVE
<=== BACK TO "DONE WELL, ACTIVISM IS A DELIGHT and IT CREATES CAREERS for YOU as well as PLANETARY EVOLUTION"
<=== BACK TO THE MALTHUSIAN INDEX PAGE
<===BACK TO THE PHILOSOPHY INDEX PAGE
<=== BACK TO THE LUCK IN LOVE WEBSITE
<== BACK TO THE PROPAGANDA STUDIES WEBSITE, HOW GOV LIES TO YOU
<=== BACK TO ALL POINTS OF THE COMPASS POLITICAL PHILOSOPHY TUTORIAL
<=== BACK TO JERRY'S REFRIGERATOR & the Tin Foil Hat Collection of CONSPIRACY THEORIES!
<====BACK TO THE FREE MONEY WEBSITE
<==== BACK TO THE HARD TIMES WEBSITE
<===== BACK TO THE POVERTY INDEX PAGE
<== BACK TO THE SNOOKERED INDEX PAGE
<===BACK TO THE REALITY 101 SEMINAR FOR TEENS
<==== BACK TO THE SHOW BUSINESS ARCHIVE
<====HOW TO TINKER WITH OTHER PEOPLE's BRAINS
<====BACK TO THE NEW AGE EMPOWERING INDEX
<===BACK TO "HOW TO MERCHANDISE YOURSELF" INDEX
<===BACK TO THE ALL ABOUT TAXES INDEX PAGE
<=== MEET ANITA SANDS WHO WRITES ALL THESE ARTICLES
<=== TAKE ME TO THE HOLISTIC PET, HOW NEVER TO NEED a VET
<===== TAKE ME TO THE SALMONELLA TIMES, HOW TO SAVE THE CHICKEN
<=== BACK TO THE TRUTHS ABOUT DENTISTRY THAT WILL SAVE YOU 100 THOUSAND!
<=== BACK TO THE SNOOKERED WEBPAGE, HOAXES WE HAVE ALL KNOWN
<===BACK TO EVERYTHING YOU NEED TO KNOW ABOUT WEB STUFF (for dummies)
<===BEAUTIES, HOW TO MARRY A BILLIONAIRE AND SAVE THE WORLD<=== HOW TO START AN INTERNAT'L CHARITY, SALARY YOURSELF AND SAVE THE WORLD<=== BACK TO HOW THE POOR MAN CAN BUY REAL ESTATE SEMINAR
<=== BACK TO PSYCH CAREERS FOR MAKING MONEY NOW, TANTRUM YOGA
<===BACK TO the 1,001 LIFE 101 ARTICLES
<====BACK TO THE PSYCHOLOGY INDEX